Bid Rigging in China: How the Crime Is Proved, How Defendants Push Back
Collusive bidding is common in the tendering market, yet once it crosses the criminal threshold, bidders, tenderees and even the staff who prepared the documents can be held liable. This article sets out the elements, the 'serious circumstances' thresholds, defence angles and practical compliance steps.
1. One phone call can change everything: why 'accompanying bids' get prosecuted
The typical fact pattern is mundane: the head of a construction company gets a call from a peer asking him to 'accompany' a bid — submit a higher price as instructed, and a thank-you payment follows. Within the industry this is treated as a favour among acquaintances. Legally, however, Articles 39 and 40 of the Regulations on the Implementation of the Bidding Law treat 'bidders consulting one another on bid prices' as collusive bidding outright; once the amounts reach the criminal filing threshold, the matter escalates from administrative penalty to criminal case. Article 223 of the Criminal Law covers two situations: bidders collusively agreeing on bid prices to the detriment of the tenderee or other bidders where circumstances are serious, and a bidder colluding with the tenderee to the detriment of the state, collectives or citizens. Both carry up to three years' imprisonment or criminal detention, with a fine, or a fine alone. Note that this is a 'circumstances' offence: conduct below the threshold can still void the award and trigger fines and disqualification from tendering for a period. 'Not criminal' does not mean 'no risk'.
2. 'Serious circumstances' is the dividing line: reading the filing thresholds
The 2022 Provisions on the Filing and Prosecution Standards for Criminal Cases under Public Security Organs (II) list several triggers for bid rigging: direct economic loss of RMB 500,000 or more; illegal gains of RMB 200,000 or more; a winning contract value of RMB 4 million or more; use of threats, deception or bribery to rig a bid; and rigging again within two years after two or more administrative penalties for the same conduct. The first task in a defence is rarely rhetoric but arithmetic — checking how each figure is calculated. Does 'direct economic loss' quietly include indirect loss and expected profit? Do 'illegal gains' mean the contract price, the project margin, or merely the fee received for accompanying the bid? Should the contract value be net of subcontracted portions that never required tendering? Different readings can move a case from criminal to administrative, or the reverse. Even where the figures are met, causation between the conduct and the loss must still be examined, together with whether the conduct qualifies as obviously minor and harmless.
3. Core defence angles: who, agreement, and harm
First, is the accused a proper subject? The offence targets bidders and tenderees. An employee who merely prepared the documents on the company's instruction will ordinarily be assessed as a directly responsible person within a unit crime rather than an independent offender; whether he had decision-making authority or personally profited requires evidence. Second, was there a genuine agreement? Coinciding prices, the same agency handling several bids, and near-identical documents are the circumstantial evidence investigators rely on — but each admits innocent explanations: a shared template, the same print shop, an industry where quotes naturally cluster. The defence task is to convert 'possible' into 'not excluded'. Third, harm and wrongfulness. Article 223(1) requires detriment to the tenderee or other bidders; Article 223(2) requires detriment to the lawful interests of the state, collectives or citizens. Where the tender failed, where the tenderee suffered no price disadvantage, or where the tenderee itself orchestrated and knew of the arrangement, the analysis shifts considerably. Fourth, concurrence of offences. Paying tenderee staff or evaluation experts to secure the award may additionally constitute bribery or accepting bribes as a non-state functionary; whether these are punished cumulatively is contested in practice, and each act should be assessed separately rather than bundled into one charge.
4. Where criminal and civil consequences meet: what happens to the contract price
The most direct civil consequence of bid rigging is that the award is void. Article 53 of the Bidding Law so provides, and under Article 1 of the Supreme People's Court Interpretation (I) on Construction Contract Disputes, where a project subject to mandatory tendering is awarded invalidly, the construction contract concluded on that basis is void. A void contract does not, however, mean the contractor goes unpaid: where the works pass inspection, the contractor may claim compensation by reference to the contract price terms. The familiar difficulty is that once criminal proceedings begin, the employer refuses payment on the ground of invalidity, sometimes demanding return of sums already paid. The two tracks must be run separately: in criminal proceedings, pursue voluntary surrender, restitution and plea leniency; in civil proceedings, secure quantity confirmations, inspection records and settlement documents early, and if necessary sue for compensation by reference to the contract price rather than waiting. Note also that tender documents, evaluation records and bank flows in such projects are simultaneously criminal and civil evidence; the sequence of obtaining and adducing them should be planned in advance.
5. What companies and individuals can do before anything happens
First, write 'accompanying bids' into the company's red lines: who prepares tender documents, who sets prices, and whether the company may prepare documents for another bidder should all be governed by written process and authorisation records. Second, separate document preparation from bidding decisions so that one person does not serve several bidders and invite an inference of collusion. Third, keep the basis on which each price was independently derived — cost worksheets, quotation records, historical price comparisons — the most direct answer to an allegation that prices were suspiciously aligned. Fourth, once investigated, assess compliance rectification and non-prosecution options promptly; bid rigging is among the offences more commonly handled through corporate compliance reform, but only on the basis of truthful statement, disgorgement of illegal gains and a verifiable remedial mechanism, not a hastily assembled set of policies. Fifth, audit completed projects for derivative exposure — bribery to win awards, false invoicing, inflated costs — so that one charge does not unravel into a series of cases.
6. Conclusion
Bid rigging is not a charge that dissolves because 'everyone in the industry does it'. Its threshold is drawn in numbers, and the defence space lies largely in how those numbers are calculated and whether an agreement can actually be proved. For defendants and their families, the most valuable step is usually not hunting for connections but organising the transaction structure, the money flows and the decision chain at the earliest stage of investigation, so that the facts are recorded in a defensible way. For companies, real risk control happens before the bid is submitted, not after the case is opened. This article is general legal information only and does not constitute legal advice on any specific matter; individual cases should be assessed by a practising lawyer in light of the evidence and local practice.
※ This article is general legal information, not legal advice on any specific matter. For your individual case, please consult a lawyer.
← All articles